A Jersey Shore Make-under

Aired on: June 10, 2010, February 15, 2010

MTV's Jersey Shore attracted millions of viewers in its first season, and no doubt many of those fans were tuning in to see the over-the-top pumps, plunging necklines and poofy hair donned by Nicole "Snooki", Sammi "Sweetheart" and Jenni "J-Woww." When the ladies sit down with Rachael, they make no excuses for their racy wardrobe. "When we go out, we like to be the center of attention," explains Nicole, "so we like to look good, obviously."

Their outfits may be suitable for clubbing at the shore, but to see if the ladies would be comfortable with a toned-down look for everyday life, Gretta takes on the challenge of giving them all a make-under. "This is a dream come true for me - I'm so psyched, but I'm also a little afraid!" Gretta says. "I think they're gorgeous, so I want to switch it up and see if they feel if they can be gorgeous in something different!"

Watch the video above for their shocking new looks, and "Snooki's" not-so-subtle reaction to her "PTA mom" outfit!